The Upsell That Actually Works (Lessons From Big Brands)

Let’s be honest, most upsells feel gross.
“Would you like fries with that?” … No thanks, I just ordered a salad.
“Upgrade to premium today!” … Why? I only signed up five minutes ago.

The problem isn’t the upsell itself. The problem is the timing, the relevance, and the psychology behind it. Done right, upselling isn’t pushy; it feels helpful. Some of the world’s biggest brands have nailed this, and here’s what we can learn from them.

Amazon: The Master of “Helpful” Upsells

When you add an item to your basket, Amazon immediately shows:

  • “Frequently Bought Together” bundles

  • “Customers Also Bought” suggestions

Why does it work?

  • It feels like social proof (“others like me bought this”).

  • It saves time (helping the customer complete their order).

  • It’s subtle. You’re already buying, they just add to it.

Result? Amazon earns billions in extra revenue each year from these nudges.

Netflix: The Upsell That Keeps You Subscribed

Netflix doesn’t ask you to “upgrade” or “spend more.” Their upsell is about engagement.

  • The recommendation algorithm pushes shows you’re most likely to binge.

  • Autoplay removes friction. You don’t choose, you just keep watching.

The psychology: make the customer’s life easier, reduce choices, and keep them engaged. The upsell is invisible, but powerful.

Why Most Upsells Fail

  • They’re badly timed (asking for more before proving value).

  • They’re irrelevant (offering fries with a salad).

  • They feel self-serving, not customer-serving.

What Actually Works

The upsells that convert are:

  • Relevant: Connected to the original purchase.

  • Timely: Offered when the customer already sees value.

  • Helpful: Feels like you’re doing them a favor, not extracting more money.

The Takeaway

The best upsell doesn’t feel like an upsell. It feels like an upgrade to the customer’s life. Amazon, Netflix, and other giants don’t just sell more, they make the customer’s journey smoother.

Back to blog